July 12, 2025
The Mysterious Disappearance of Jennifer Kessie: Unsolved True Crime Case Haunts Orlando Community for Years
What happens when a vibrant young woman simply vanishes without a trace? In this gripping episode of True Crime, Authors & Extraordinary People, host David McClam takes you on a haunting journey into the unsolved disappearance of Jennifer Kessie, a 24-year-old woman who mysteriously vanished from her Orlando condo in January 2006. This case remains one of the most perplexing unsolved mysteries in recent history, and as we peel back the layers, the chilling details will leave you questioning everything.
As McClam recounts the eerie circumstances surrounding Jennifer's disappearance, listeners will be drawn into the unsettling scene discovered by her distraught parents. The abandoned car, the cryptic surveillance footage capturing an unidentified individual, and the unsettling whispers of those who worked in her building create a tapestry of intrigue and fear. Could the construction workers who frequented her condo have played a role in her abduction? Jennifer had expressed discomfort around them, and this theory has haunted investigators and true crime enthusiasts alike.
Despite a relentless investigation, extensive media coverage, and a staggering $500,000 reward for information, Jennifer's case remains cold nearly two decades later. The urgency for justice echoes throughout this episode as McClam emphasizes the need for the public's help. The episode serves not only as a reminder of the fragility of safety but also as a call to action for anyone who might hold a key piece of information that could lead to answers for Jennifer's family.
Join us as we delve deep into the heart of this tragic story, exploring the emotional toll on Jennifer's loved ones and the relentless pursuit of truth. True Crime, Authors & Extraordinary People is more than just a podcast; it's a platform for the unheard voices of those affected by crime. We invite you to listen, reflect, and share your thoughts. Your insights could be the catalyst for justice in a case that has haunted so many for years.
Don't miss this opportunity to engage with a case that highlights the importance of community involvement in solving crimes. Tune in and help us keep the conversation alive, because every detail matters, and every listener could be the one to crack the case. Together, let’s strive for justice for Jennifer Kessie and honor her memory as we explore the darker side of humanity in this compelling episode.
DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE
JOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA BY FOLLOWING THE LINKTREE
Follow Our Family Of True Crime Shows
apple. com/us/podcast/lost-girls/id1644959659">Lost Girls with LaDonna Humphrey & Amy Smith
apple. com/us/podcast/extinguished/id1711608332">Extinguished With David McClam & LaDonna Humphrey
Cover Art and Logo created by Diana of Other Worldly
Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam
Intro script by Sophie Wild & David McClam
Intro and outro jingle by Jacqueline G. (JacquieVoice)
Hosted by Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy for more information.
Transcript
WEBVTT
1
00:00:04.452 --> 00:00:05.994
Welcome to True Crime,
2
00:00:06.373 --> 00:00:08.518
Authors and Extraordinary People,
3
00:00:09.057 --> 00:00:12.061
the podcast where we bring two passions together.
4
00:00:12.658 --> 00:00:15.525
The show that gives new meaning to the old adage,
5
00:00:16.025 --> 00:00:18.049
truth is stranger than fiction.
6
00:00:18.744 --> 00:00:23.033
And reminding you that there is an extraordinary person in all of us.
7
00:00:23.658 --> 00:00:24.518
Here is your host,
8
00:00:24.939 --> 00:00:25.799
David McClain.
9
00:00:26.189 --> 00:00:28.549
What's going on everybody and welcome to another episode of True Crime,
10
00:00:28.643 --> 00:00:29.814
Authors and Extraordinary People.
11
00:00:29.815 --> 00:00:30.299
Of course,
12
00:00:30.393 --> 00:00:31.221
I'm your man.
13
00:00:31.820 --> 00:00:32.841
David McClam,
14
00:00:32.900 --> 00:00:33.920
if you guys haven't already,
15
00:00:34.500 --> 00:00:36.142
make sure you follow us on all of our social media.
16
00:00:36.783 --> 00:00:41.826
One link to a link tree will get you every place you need to go pertaining to the show.
17
00:00:42.521 --> 00:00:43.920
And like I always remind you,
18
00:00:44.060 --> 00:00:48.521
if you are someone or you know someone that feel like you want to hurt yourself or others,
19
00:00:48.959 --> 00:00:52.506
please leave this episode and dial 988.
20
00:00:52.990 --> 00:00:55.427
It's a suicide prevention hotline.
21
00:00:55.771 --> 00:00:57.584
You can text or call them.
22
00:00:57.990 --> 00:01:00.506
They can get you the help that you need.
23
00:01:00.956 --> 00:01:03.618
And just in case no one else has told you this today,
24
00:01:04.198 --> 00:01:10.148
let me be the first to tell you that I do care and I do need you to be here.
25
00:01:10.663 --> 00:01:13.929
There is nothing that is worth your life.
26
00:01:15.632 --> 00:01:16.749
And if you like what we do here,
27
00:01:16.773 --> 00:01:17.765
you want to support the show,
28
00:01:17.952 --> 00:01:18.921
CrowdWeave.
29
00:01:18.999 --> 00:01:20.530
Link is in the show notes.
30
00:01:20.593 --> 00:01:24.624
It is a fun way for me to give back to you for supporting the show.
31
00:01:25.062 --> 00:01:26.765
And if you just want to simply buy me a coffee,
32
00:01:27.140 --> 00:01:29.390
you can do that at that link down below as well.
33
00:01:30.048 --> 00:01:33.210
One dollar is all that it takes.
34
00:01:34.492 --> 00:01:34.972
Today,
35
00:01:35.913 --> 00:01:38.714
we are covering a case that has haunted investigators,
36
00:01:39.238 --> 00:01:39.855
journalists,
37
00:01:40.339 --> 00:01:44.581
and the Kessie family for now nearly 20 years.
38
00:01:45.480 --> 00:01:45.800
Today,
39
00:01:45.871 --> 00:01:49.105
we're going to talk about the disappearance of Jennifer Kessie.
40
00:01:51.760 --> 00:01:52.381
Jennifer was a
41
00:01:52.902 --> 00:01:54.223
24-year-old woman living in Orlando,
42
00:01:54.323 --> 00:01:54.662
Florida.
43
00:01:55.123 --> 00:01:57.006
She had just bought her first condo,
44
00:01:57.666 --> 00:01:59.846
landed a great job at a timeshare company,
45
00:02:00.408 --> 00:02:01.690
and was building her future.
46
00:02:02.791 --> 00:02:04.174
But on January 24,
47
00:02:04.213 --> 00:02:05.494
2006,
48
00:02:06.151 --> 00:02:07.791
Jennifer vanished without a trace.
49
00:02:08.619 --> 00:02:12.197
Her disappearance is one of Florida's most frustrating and well-known mysteries,
50
00:02:12.401 --> 00:02:14.369
with surveillance footage that leaves nowhere,
51
00:02:14.963 --> 00:02:16.697
eerie details inside her home,
52
00:02:17.041 --> 00:02:20.635
and a theory that points to construction workers living in her complex.
53
00:02:21.620 --> 00:02:23.941
So what really happened to Jennifer Kessie?
54
00:02:24.920 --> 00:02:25.602
And why,
55
00:02:26.422 --> 00:02:28.043
after nearly two decades,
56
00:02:28.461 --> 00:02:30.500
does this case remain unsolved?
57
00:02:31.703 --> 00:02:31.820
Well,
58
00:02:31.859 --> 00:02:32.805
let's get into it.
59
00:02:34.086 --> 00:02:34.203
See,
60
00:02:34.266 --> 00:02:36.766
Jennifer was last heard from on the night of January
61
00:02:37.320 --> 00:02:38.578
23rd, 2006.
62
00:02:39.281 --> 00:02:41.891
She had just returned from a vacation with her boyfriend,
63
00:02:41.969 --> 00:02:42.625
Rob Allen.
64
00:02:43.328 --> 00:02:45.391
They talked on the phone before she went to bed,
65
00:02:45.719 --> 00:02:47.000
and by all accounts,
66
00:02:47.641 --> 00:02:49.047
everything seemed normal.
67
00:02:50.048 --> 00:02:51.089
But the next morning,
68
00:02:51.210 --> 00:02:52.792
Jennifer never showed up for work.
69
00:02:53.491 --> 00:02:55.854
This was immediately out of character for her.
70
00:02:56.596 --> 00:02:57.815
She was responsible,
71
00:02:58.120 --> 00:02:58.714
punctual,
72
00:02:59.214 --> 00:03:02.901
and always checked in with her family and her co-workers.
73
00:03:03.964 --> 00:03:05.081
When her job called,
74
00:03:05.206 --> 00:03:05.846
her parents,
75
00:03:05.964 --> 00:03:07.229
Drew and Joyce Kessie,
76
00:03:07.932 --> 00:03:09.651
they immediately knew something was wrong.
77
00:03:10.448 --> 00:03:10.901
Her father,
78
00:03:10.964 --> 00:03:11.151
Drew,
79
00:03:11.245 --> 00:03:12.307
told Fox News that,
80
00:03:12.323 --> 00:03:12.807
I quote,
81
00:03:13.495 --> 00:03:14.526
We don't care when,
82
00:03:15.120 --> 00:03:16.057
we don't care how,
83
00:03:16.089 --> 00:03:16.636
and frankly,
84
00:03:16.667 --> 00:03:17.417
we don't care who.
85
00:03:18.208 --> 00:03:21.432
We just want our daughter back for the good or the bad.
86
00:03:22.051 --> 00:03:23.495
We miss her every day.
87
00:03:24.296 --> 00:03:24.756
End quote.
88
00:03:25.495 --> 00:03:28.499
Jennifer's parents rushed to her condo expecting to find their daughter.
89
00:03:29.202 --> 00:03:29.616
Instead,
90
00:03:29.663 --> 00:03:32.046
they walked into a strange and eerie scene.
91
00:03:33.303 --> 00:03:34.561
Jennifer's car was missing.
92
00:03:35.483 --> 00:03:37.514
A damp towel lay in the bathroom.
93
00:03:38.467 --> 00:03:40.374
Pajamas were tossed on the floor.
94
00:03:41.374 --> 00:03:42.327
Her iPod,
95
00:03:42.717 --> 00:03:43.233
keys,
96
00:03:43.686 --> 00:03:44.389
cell phone,
97
00:03:44.436 --> 00:03:46.952
and purse were nowhere to be found.
98
00:03:48.264 --> 00:03:50.886
Her hair straightener was still plugged in.
99
00:03:52.249 --> 00:03:52.390
See,
100
00:03:52.429 --> 00:03:55.311
everything pointed to Jennifer getting ready for work that morning,
101
00:03:55.913 --> 00:03:57.952
but she never made it out of the condo.
102
00:03:59.358 --> 00:04:00.413
Then two days later,
103
00:04:00.476 --> 00:04:03.577
police found her car abandoned at a nearby apartment complex.
104
00:04:04.515 --> 00:04:08.765
This was the first and biggest clue in the case.
105
00:04:09.890 --> 00:04:10.030
Now,
106
00:04:10.093 --> 00:04:12.171
here's where it gets even stranger.
107
00:04:13.480 --> 00:04:20.488
Surveillance cameras at the apartment complex where Jennifer's car was found captured a person parking it and then walking away.
108
00:04:21.668 --> 00:04:23.629
But in a frustrating twist of fate,
109
00:04:24.129 --> 00:04:29.731
the camera's frames captured the suspect behind the gate post every few seconds,
110
00:04:30.715 --> 00:04:32.199
obscuring their face completely.
111
00:04:33.481 --> 00:04:39.340
All police could determine was that the person was between 5'3 and 5'5 inches tall.
112
00:04:40.156 --> 00:04:42.922
Even NASA was brought in to analyze the footage,
113
00:04:43.223 --> 00:04:47.250
but not even their technology could positively identify the suspect.
114
00:04:48.027 --> 00:04:49.754
So who was this person?
115
00:04:50.855 --> 00:04:53.558
Jennifer's family has one major theory.
116
00:04:55.301 --> 00:04:57.840
It is called the construction worker theory.
117
00:05:00.192 --> 00:05:00.332
See,
118
00:05:00.373 --> 00:05:03.234
Jennifer's condo was under heavy construction at the time.
119
00:05:03.996 --> 00:05:08.379
Her father later told Fox News that Jennifer had felt uneasy around the workers.
120
00:05:09.144 --> 00:05:11.566
She even mentioned to her family the workers would stare at her,
121
00:05:12.144 --> 00:05:13.309
stop what they were doing,
122
00:05:13.769 --> 00:05:16.176
or even enter her condo unannounced.
123
00:05:17.082 --> 00:05:18.988
Private investigator Michael Toretta,
124
00:05:19.504 --> 00:05:20.973
hired by the Kessie family,
125
00:05:21.113 --> 00:05:22.332
believes this is key.
126
00:05:23.238 --> 00:05:27.379
He discovered that up to 10 workers were living in a vacant unit across from Jennifer.
127
00:05:28.228 --> 00:05:31.031
And here's what he theorized on 48 hours.
128
00:05:31.711 --> 00:05:32.393
And I quote,
129
00:05:33.014 --> 00:05:35.834
I believe Jennifer was abducted immediately after locking her door.
130
00:05:36.299 --> 00:05:37.815
She probably never saw it coming.
131
00:05:38.315 --> 00:05:41.041
She was dragged into the unit across the hall.
132
00:05:41.658 --> 00:05:43.002
And that's where it ended.
133
00:05:44.197 --> 00:05:45.510
It's a horrifying thought,
134
00:05:45.947 --> 00:05:47.572
but one that makes sense.
135
00:05:48.401 --> 00:05:54.276
Jennifer's car was seen speeding out of her condo parking lot around 740 a.m.
136
00:05:54.682 --> 00:05:55.979
The morning she disappeared.
137
00:05:56.844 --> 00:05:58.185
Did someone ambush her,
138
00:05:58.887 --> 00:06:00.367
force her into her own car,
139
00:06:00.629 --> 00:06:02.051
and drive her to another location?
140
00:06:03.172 --> 00:06:04.672
And here's another chilling detail.
141
00:06:05.555 --> 00:06:13.242
A full set of master keys to the entire complex went missing just one month before Jennifer disappeared.
142
00:06:15.039 --> 00:06:19.773
Could someone have used those stolen keys to access Jennifer's condo?
143
00:06:20.711 --> 00:06:23.773
Jennifer's case has seen countless twists and turns,
144
00:06:24.773 --> 00:06:25.914
but no real answers.
145
00:06:27.204 --> 00:06:28.025
Unfortunately,
146
00:06:28.585 --> 00:06:38.736
the scene inside her condo was compromised because her family and friends unknowingly disturbed potential forensic evidence before police arrived.
147
00:06:39.478 --> 00:06:41.056
And despite the reward money,
148
00:06:41.478 --> 00:06:44.283
national coverage and private investigations,
149
00:06:44.923 --> 00:06:47.658
no concrete leads have surfaced.
150
00:06:48.798 --> 00:06:50.673
Jennifer's family refuses to give up.
151
00:06:51.486 --> 00:06:52.392
In 2019,
152
00:06:52.470 --> 00:06:55.439
they offered a $500,000 reward.
153
00:06:55.904 --> 00:06:57.885
for information leading to her whereabouts.
154
00:06:58.827 --> 00:07:00.188
And in 2025,
155
00:07:00.708 --> 00:07:02.411
they shared a heartbreaking message.
156
00:07:03.270 --> 00:07:03.895
And I quote,
157
00:07:05.614 --> 00:07:11.637
How can a missing person's case with such awareness not produce even a direction 19 years later?
158
00:07:12.895 --> 00:07:14.083
It's inconceivable,
159
00:07:14.895 --> 00:07:17.286
but we fight on for Jennifer's sake.
160
00:07:18.520 --> 00:07:24.989
The disappearance of Jennifer Kesey remains one of the most baffling and heartbreaking cold cases in the U.S.
161
00:07:25.968 --> 00:07:29.428
If she was abducted by someone in her condo complex,
162
00:07:30.348 --> 00:07:33.590
how has there never been a confession?
163
00:07:34.848 --> 00:07:36.707
That gives you something to think about.
164
00:07:36.770 --> 00:07:38.832
After all these years,
165
00:07:39.871 --> 00:07:43.676
if she was taken by someone in her condo,
166
00:07:44.676 --> 00:07:47.020
somebody should have seen something.
167
00:07:47.411 --> 00:07:48.395
So I implore you,
168
00:07:48.817 --> 00:07:51.254
if you know anything about what happened to Jennifer,
169
00:07:51.395 --> 00:07:52.598
please contact.
170
00:07:53.236 --> 00:08:00.024
the Orlando Police Department at 407-246-2979,
171
00:08:00.664 --> 00:08:03.364
or submit tips to the Kessie family's website,
172
00:08:03.989 --> 00:08:05.785
jenniferkessie.com.
173
00:08:06.989 --> 00:08:09.074
Jennifer's family deserves answers,
174
00:08:09.770 --> 00:08:12.598
and Jennifer deserves justice.
175
00:08:15.317 --> 00:08:15.582
All right,
176
00:08:15.583 --> 00:08:15.817
guys,
177
00:08:15.864 --> 00:08:18.817
thank you once again for joining me for this episode.
178
00:08:19.828 --> 00:08:24.772
The phone number to the Orlando Police Department and the Kesey family website will be posted in the show notes.
179
00:08:24.834 --> 00:08:25.272
Again,
180
00:08:25.354 --> 00:08:26.854
if you know anything,
181
00:08:26.916 --> 00:08:28.854
the slightest thing at all,
182
00:08:30.018 --> 00:08:34.260
call the police or send that tip into the Kesey family's website,
183
00:08:34.299 --> 00:08:35.706
JenniferKesey.com.
184
00:08:36.206 --> 00:08:40.252
It's time for whoever did this to step out of the shadows,
185
00:08:40.924 --> 00:08:43.518
admit to his or her crime,
186
00:08:44.424 --> 00:08:45.034
and give
187
00:08:45.456 --> 00:08:49.331
Jennifer and her family the justice that they need.
188
00:08:50.148 --> 00:08:51.169
and most importantly,
189
00:08:51.709 --> 00:08:52.410
deserve.
190
00:08:54.754 --> 00:08:55.031
All right,
191
00:08:55.074 --> 00:08:55.512
once again,
192
00:08:55.613 --> 00:08:57.196
thank you for joining us today.
193
00:08:57.414 --> 00:09:00.555
I know you have many choices in True Crime and Interview Podcasts,
194
00:09:01.180 --> 00:09:02.258
and I'm grateful that
195
00:09:02.664 --> 00:09:04.485
I am one of your choices.
196
00:09:05.086 --> 00:09:10.227
You have been listening to the only three-faceted podcast of its kind.
197
00:09:10.821 --> 00:09:13.336
Be good to yourself and each other,
198
00:09:14.164 --> 00:09:15.352
and always remember,
199
00:09:16.758 --> 00:09:17.758
always stay humble.
200
00:09:18.672 --> 00:09:21.015
An act of kindness can make someone's day.
201
00:09:21.915 --> 00:09:24.376
A little love and compassion can go a long way.
202
00:09:25.357 --> 00:09:30.700
And remember that there is an extraordinary person in all of us.
203
00:09:31.505 --> 00:09:33.365
I'll catch you guys on the next one.
204
00:09:37.536 --> 00:09:38.677
Don't forget to rate,
205
00:09:38.755 --> 00:09:39.146
comment,
206
00:09:39.240 --> 00:09:40.068
and subscribe.
207
00:09:40.552 --> 00:09:41.693
Join us on social media.
208
00:09:42.349 --> 00:09:44.052
One link to the link tree has it all.
209
00:09:44.802 --> 00:09:47.677
Feel free to drop us a line at True Crime and Authors.
210
00:09:47.996 --> 00:09:49.218
at gmail.com.
211
00:09:49.820 --> 00:09:52.205
Cover art and logo designed by Arsla.
212
00:09:52.826 --> 00:09:55.208
Sound mixing and editing by David McClam.
213
00:09:55.966 --> 00:09:58.755
Intro script by Soapy Wild and David McClam.
214
00:09:59.614 --> 00:10:00.195
Theme music,
215
00:10:00.536 --> 00:10:02.460
Legendary by New Alchemist.
216
00:10:03.081 --> 00:10:06.065
Introduction and ending credits by Jackie Voice.
217
00:10:06.827 --> 00:10:08.792
See you next time on True Crime,
218
00:10:09.050 --> 00:10:09.495
Authors,
219
00:10:09.753 --> 00:10:10.995
and Extraordinary People.
1
00:00:04.452 --> 00:00:05.994
Welcome to True Crime,
2
00:00:06.373 --> 00:00:08.518
Authors and Extraordinary People,
3
00:00:09.057 --> 00:00:12.061
the podcast where we bring two passions together.
4
00:00:12.658 --> 00:00:15.525
The show that gives new meaning to the old adage,
5
00:00:16.025 --> 00:00:18.049
truth is stranger than fiction.
6
00:00:18.744 --> 00:00:23.033
And reminding you that there is an extraordinary person in all of us.
7
00:00:23.658 --> 00:00:24.518
Here is your host,
8
00:00:24.939 --> 00:00:25.799
David McClain.
9
00:00:26.189 --> 00:00:28.549
What's going on everybody and welcome to another episode of True Crime,
10
00:00:28.643 --> 00:00:29.814
Authors and Extraordinary People.
11
00:00:29.815 --> 00:00:30.299
Of course,
12
00:00:30.393 --> 00:00:31.221
I'm your man.
13
00:00:31.820 --> 00:00:32.841
David McClam,
14
00:00:32.900 --> 00:00:33.920
if you guys haven't already,
15
00:00:34.500 --> 00:00:36.142
make sure you follow us on all of our social media.
16
00:00:36.783 --> 00:00:41.826
One link to a link tree will get you every place you need to go pertaining to the show.
17
00:00:42.521 --> 00:00:43.920
And like I always remind you,
18
00:00:44.060 --> 00:00:48.521
if you are someone or you know someone that feel like you want to hurt yourself or others,
19
00:00:48.959 --> 00:00:52.506
please leave this episode and dial 988.
20
00:00:52.990 --> 00:00:55.427
It's a suicide prevention hotline.
21
00:00:55.771 --> 00:00:57.584
You can text or call them.
22
00:00:57.990 --> 00:01:00.506
They can get you the help that you need.
23
00:01:00.956 --> 00:01:03.618
And just in case no one else has told you this today,
24
00:01:04.198 --> 00:01:10.148
let me be the first to tell you that I do care and I do need you to be here.
25
00:01:10.663 --> 00:01:13.929
There is nothing that is worth your life.
26
00:01:15.632 --> 00:01:16.749
And if you like what we do here,
27
00:01:16.773 --> 00:01:17.765
you want to support the show,
28
00:01:17.952 --> 00:01:18.921
CrowdWeave.
29
00:01:18.999 --> 00:01:20.530
Link is in the show notes.
30
00:01:20.593 --> 00:01:24.624
It is a fun way for me to give back to you for supporting the show.
31
00:01:25.062 --> 00:01:26.765
And if you just want to simply buy me a coffee,
32
00:01:27.140 --> 00:01:29.390
you can do that at that link down below as well.
33
00:01:30.048 --> 00:01:33.210
One dollar is all that it takes.
34
00:01:34.492 --> 00:01:34.972
Today,
35
00:01:35.913 --> 00:01:38.714
we are covering a case that has haunted investigators,
36
00:01:39.238 --> 00:01:39.855
journalists,
37
00:01:40.339 --> 00:01:44.581
and the Kessie family for now nearly 20 years.
38
00:01:45.480 --> 00:01:45.800
Today,
39
00:01:45.871 --> 00:01:49.105
we're going to talk about the disappearance of Jennifer Kessie.
40
00:01:51.760 --> 00:01:52.381
Jennifer was a
41
00:01:52.902 --> 00:01:54.223
24-year-old woman living in Orlando,
42
00:01:54.323 --> 00:01:54.662
Florida.
43
00:01:55.123 --> 00:01:57.006
She had just bought her first condo,
44
00:01:57.666 --> 00:01:59.846
landed a great job at a timeshare company,
45
00:02:00.408 --> 00:02:01.690
and was building her future.
46
00:02:02.791 --> 00:02:04.174
But on January 24,
47
00:02:04.213 --> 00:02:05.494
2006,
48
00:02:06.151 --> 00:02:07.791
Jennifer vanished without a trace.
49
00:02:08.619 --> 00:02:12.197
Her disappearance is one of Florida's most frustrating and well-known mysteries,
50
00:02:12.401 --> 00:02:14.369
with surveillance footage that leaves nowhere,
51
00:02:14.963 --> 00:02:16.697
eerie details inside her home,
52
00:02:17.041 --> 00:02:20.635
and a theory that points to construction workers living in her complex.
53
00:02:21.620 --> 00:02:23.941
So what really happened to Jennifer Kessie?
54
00:02:24.920 --> 00:02:25.602
And why,
55
00:02:26.422 --> 00:02:28.043
after nearly two decades,
56
00:02:28.461 --> 00:02:30.500
does this case remain unsolved?
57
00:02:31.703 --> 00:02:31.820
Well,
58
00:02:31.859 --> 00:02:32.805
let's get into it.
59
00:02:34.086 --> 00:02:34.203
See,
60
00:02:34.266 --> 00:02:36.766
Jennifer was last heard from on the night of January
61
00:02:37.320 --> 00:02:38.578
23rd, 2006.
62
00:02:39.281 --> 00:02:41.891
She had just returned from a vacation with her boyfriend,
63
00:02:41.969 --> 00:02:42.625
Rob Allen.
64
00:02:43.328 --> 00:02:45.391
They talked on the phone before she went to bed,
65
00:02:45.719 --> 00:02:47.000
and by all accounts,
66
00:02:47.641 --> 00:02:49.047
everything seemed normal.
67
00:02:50.048 --> 00:02:51.089
But the next morning,
68
00:02:51.210 --> 00:02:52.792
Jennifer never showed up for work.
69
00:02:53.491 --> 00:02:55.854
This was immediately out of character for her.
70
00:02:56.596 --> 00:02:57.815
She was responsible,
71
00:02:58.120 --> 00:02:58.714
punctual,
72
00:02:59.214 --> 00:03:02.901
and always checked in with her family and her co-workers.
73
00:03:03.964 --> 00:03:05.081
When her job called,
74
00:03:05.206 --> 00:03:05.846
her parents,
75
00:03:05.964 --> 00:03:07.229
Drew and Joyce Kessie,
76
00:03:07.932 --> 00:03:09.651
they immediately knew something was wrong.
77
00:03:10.448 --> 00:03:10.901
Her father,
78
00:03:10.964 --> 00:03:11.151
Drew,
79
00:03:11.245 --> 00:03:12.307
told Fox News that,
80
00:03:12.323 --> 00:03:12.807
I quote,
81
00:03:13.495 --> 00:03:14.526
We don't care when,
82
00:03:15.120 --> 00:03:16.057
we don't care how,
83
00:03:16.089 --> 00:03:16.636
and frankly,
84
00:03:16.667 --> 00:03:17.417
we don't care who.
85
00:03:18.208 --> 00:03:21.432
We just want our daughter back for the good or the bad.
86
00:03:22.051 --> 00:03:23.495
We miss her every day.
87
00:03:24.296 --> 00:03:24.756
End quote.
88
00:03:25.495 --> 00:03:28.499
Jennifer's parents rushed to her condo expecting to find their daughter.
89
00:03:29.202 --> 00:03:29.616
Instead,
90
00:03:29.663 --> 00:03:32.046
they walked into a strange and eerie scene.
91
00:03:33.303 --> 00:03:34.561
Jennifer's car was missing.
92
00:03:35.483 --> 00:03:37.514
A damp towel lay in the bathroom.
93
00:03:38.467 --> 00:03:40.374
Pajamas were tossed on the floor.
94
00:03:41.374 --> 00:03:42.327
Her iPod,
95
00:03:42.717 --> 00:03:43.233
keys,
96
00:03:43.686 --> 00:03:44.389
cell phone,
97
00:03:44.436 --> 00:03:46.952
and purse were nowhere to be found.
98
00:03:48.264 --> 00:03:50.886
Her hair straightener was still plugged in.
99
00:03:52.249 --> 00:03:52.390
See,
100
00:03:52.429 --> 00:03:55.311
everything pointed to Jennifer getting ready for work that morning,
101
00:03:55.913 --> 00:03:57.952
but she never made it out of the condo.
102
00:03:59.358 --> 00:04:00.413
Then two days later,
103
00:04:00.476 --> 00:04:03.577
police found her car abandoned at a nearby apartment complex.
104
00:04:04.515 --> 00:04:08.765
This was the first and biggest clue in the case.
105
00:04:09.890 --> 00:04:10.030
Now,
106
00:04:10.093 --> 00:04:12.171
here's where it gets even stranger.
107
00:04:13.480 --> 00:04:20.488
Surveillance cameras at the apartment complex where Jennifer's car was found captured a person parking it and then walking away.
108
00:04:21.668 --> 00:04:23.629
But in a frustrating twist of fate,
109
00:04:24.129 --> 00:04:29.731
the camera's frames captured the suspect behind the gate post every few seconds,
110
00:04:30.715 --> 00:04:32.199
obscuring their face completely.
111
00:04:33.481 --> 00:04:39.340
All police could determine was that the person was between 5'3 and 5'5 inches tall.
112
00:04:40.156 --> 00:04:42.922
Even NASA was brought in to analyze the footage,
113
00:04:43.223 --> 00:04:47.250
but not even their technology could positively identify the suspect.
114
00:04:48.027 --> 00:04:49.754
So who was this person?
115
00:04:50.855 --> 00:04:53.558
Jennifer's family has one major theory.
116
00:04:55.301 --> 00:04:57.840
It is called the construction worker theory.
117
00:05:00.192 --> 00:05:00.332
See,
118
00:05:00.373 --> 00:05:03.234
Jennifer's condo was under heavy construction at the time.
119
00:05:03.996 --> 00:05:08.379
Her father later told Fox News that Jennifer had felt uneasy around the workers.
120
00:05:09.144 --> 00:05:11.566
She even mentioned to her family the workers would stare at her,
121
00:05:12.144 --> 00:05:13.309
stop what they were doing,
122
00:05:13.769 --> 00:05:16.176
or even enter her condo unannounced.
123
00:05:17.082 --> 00:05:18.988
Private investigator Michael Toretta,
124
00:05:19.504 --> 00:05:20.973
hired by the Kessie family,
125
00:05:21.113 --> 00:05:22.332
believes this is key.
126
00:05:23.238 --> 00:05:27.379
He discovered that up to 10 workers were living in a vacant unit across from Jennifer.
127
00:05:28.228 --> 00:05:31.031
And here's what he theorized on 48 hours.
128
00:05:31.711 --> 00:05:32.393
And I quote,
129
00:05:33.014 --> 00:05:35.834
I believe Jennifer was abducted immediately after locking her door.
130
00:05:36.299 --> 00:05:37.815
She probably never saw it coming.
131
00:05:38.315 --> 00:05:41.041
She was dragged into the unit across the hall.
132
00:05:41.658 --> 00:05:43.002
And that's where it ended.
133
00:05:44.197 --> 00:05:45.510
It's a horrifying thought,
134
00:05:45.947 --> 00:05:47.572
but one that makes sense.
135
00:05:48.401 --> 00:05:54.276
Jennifer's car was seen speeding out of her condo parking lot around 740 a.m.
136
00:05:54.682 --> 00:05:55.979
The morning she disappeared.
137
00:05:56.844 --> 00:05:58.185
Did someone ambush her,
138
00:05:58.887 --> 00:06:00.367
force her into her own car,
139
00:06:00.629 --> 00:06:02.051
and drive her to another location?
140
00:06:03.172 --> 00:06:04.672
And here's another chilling detail.
141
00:06:05.555 --> 00:06:13.242
A full set of master keys to the entire complex went missing just one month before Jennifer disappeared.
142
00:06:15.039 --> 00:06:19.773
Could someone have used those stolen keys to access Jennifer's condo?
143
00:06:20.711 --> 00:06:23.773
Jennifer's case has seen countless twists and turns,
144
00:06:24.773 --> 00:06:25.914
but no real answers.
145
00:06:27.204 --> 00:06:28.025
Unfortunately,
146
00:06:28.585 --> 00:06:38.736
the scene inside her condo was compromised because her family and friends unknowingly disturbed potential forensic evidence before police arrived.
147
00:06:39.478 --> 00:06:41.056
And despite the reward money,
148
00:06:41.478 --> 00:06:44.283
national coverage and private investigations,
149
00:06:44.923 --> 00:06:47.658
no concrete leads have surfaced.
150
00:06:48.798 --> 00:06:50.673
Jennifer's family refuses to give up.
151
00:06:51.486 --> 00:06:52.392
In 2019,
152
00:06:52.470 --> 00:06:55.439
they offered a $500,000 reward.
153
00:06:55.904 --> 00:06:57.885
for information leading to her whereabouts.
154
00:06:58.827 --> 00:07:00.188
And in 2025,
155
00:07:00.708 --> 00:07:02.411
they shared a heartbreaking message.
156
00:07:03.270 --> 00:07:03.895
And I quote,
157
00:07:05.614 --> 00:07:11.637
How can a missing person's case with such awareness not produce even a direction 19 years later?
158
00:07:12.895 --> 00:07:14.083
It's inconceivable,
159
00:07:14.895 --> 00:07:17.286
but we fight on for Jennifer's sake.
160
00:07:18.520 --> 00:07:24.989
The disappearance of Jennifer Kesey remains one of the most baffling and heartbreaking cold cases in the U.S.
161
00:07:25.968 --> 00:07:29.428
If she was abducted by someone in her condo complex,
162
00:07:30.348 --> 00:07:33.590
how has there never been a confession?
163
00:07:34.848 --> 00:07:36.707
That gives you something to think about.
164
00:07:36.770 --> 00:07:38.832
After all these years,
165
00:07:39.871 --> 00:07:43.676
if she was taken by someone in her condo,
166
00:07:44.676 --> 00:07:47.020
somebody should have seen something.
167
00:07:47.411 --> 00:07:48.395
So I implore you,
168
00:07:48.817 --> 00:07:51.254
if you know anything about what happened to Jennifer,
169
00:07:51.395 --> 00:07:52.598
please contact.
170
00:07:53.236 --> 00:08:00.024
the Orlando Police Department at 407-246-2979,
171
00:08:00.664 --> 00:08:03.364
or submit tips to the Kessie family's website,
172
00:08:03.989 --> 00:08:05.785
jenniferkessie.com.
173
00:08:06.989 --> 00:08:09.074
Jennifer's family deserves answers,
174
00:08:09.770 --> 00:08:12.598
and Jennifer deserves justice.
175
00:08:15.317 --> 00:08:15.582
All right,
176
00:08:15.583 --> 00:08:15.817
guys,
177
00:08:15.864 --> 00:08:18.817
thank you once again for joining me for this episode.
178
00:08:19.828 --> 00:08:24.772
The phone number to the Orlando Police Department and the Kesey family website will be posted in the show notes.
179
00:08:24.834 --> 00:08:25.272
Again,
180
00:08:25.354 --> 00:08:26.854
if you know anything,
181
00:08:26.916 --> 00:08:28.854
the slightest thing at all,
182
00:08:30.018 --> 00:08:34.260
call the police or send that tip into the Kesey family's website,
183
00:08:34.299 --> 00:08:35.706
JenniferKesey.com.
184
00:08:36.206 --> 00:08:40.252
It's time for whoever did this to step out of the shadows,
185
00:08:40.924 --> 00:08:43.518
admit to his or her crime,
186
00:08:44.424 --> 00:08:45.034
and give
187
00:08:45.456 --> 00:08:49.331
Jennifer and her family the justice that they need.
188
00:08:50.148 --> 00:08:51.169
and most importantly,
189
00:08:51.709 --> 00:08:52.410
deserve.
190
00:08:54.754 --> 00:08:55.031
All right,
191
00:08:55.074 --> 00:08:55.512
once again,
192
00:08:55.613 --> 00:08:57.196
thank you for joining us today.
193
00:08:57.414 --> 00:09:00.555
I know you have many choices in True Crime and Interview Podcasts,
194
00:09:01.180 --> 00:09:02.258
and I'm grateful that
195
00:09:02.664 --> 00:09:04.485
I am one of your choices.
196
00:09:05.086 --> 00:09:10.227
You have been listening to the only three-faceted podcast of its kind.
197
00:09:10.821 --> 00:09:13.336
Be good to yourself and each other,
198
00:09:14.164 --> 00:09:15.352
and always remember,
199
00:09:16.758 --> 00:09:17.758
always stay humble.
200
00:09:18.672 --> 00:09:21.015
An act of kindness can make someone's day.
201
00:09:21.915 --> 00:09:24.376
A little love and compassion can go a long way.
202
00:09:25.357 --> 00:09:30.700
And remember that there is an extraordinary person in all of us.
203
00:09:31.505 --> 00:09:33.365
I'll catch you guys on the next one.
204
00:09:37.536 --> 00:09:38.677
Don't forget to rate,
205
00:09:38.755 --> 00:09:39.146
comment,
206
00:09:39.240 --> 00:09:40.068
and subscribe.
207
00:09:40.552 --> 00:09:41.693
Join us on social media.
208
00:09:42.349 --> 00:09:44.052
One link to the link tree has it all.
209
00:09:44.802 --> 00:09:47.677
Feel free to drop us a line at True Crime and Authors.
210
00:09:47.996 --> 00:09:49.218
at gmail.com.
211
00:09:49.820 --> 00:09:52.205
Cover art and logo designed by Arsla.
212
00:09:52.826 --> 00:09:55.208
Sound mixing and editing by David McClam.
213
00:09:55.966 --> 00:09:58.755
Intro script by Soapy Wild and David McClam.
214
00:09:59.614 --> 00:10:00.195
Theme music,
215
00:10:00.536 --> 00:10:02.460
Legendary by New Alchemist.
216
00:10:03.081 --> 00:10:06.065
Introduction and ending credits by Jackie Voice.
217
00:10:06.827 --> 00:10:08.792
See you next time on True Crime,
218
00:10:09.050 --> 00:10:09.495
Authors,
219
00:10:09.753 --> 00:10:10.995
and Extraordinary People.
